Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

homemade non-fat greek frozen yogurt

I kid you not, Neal and I have had this ice cream machine for almost 2 years now and we’ve yet to use it… until Monday!

Cusinart Ice Cream Maker

Monday night I whipped up a batch of plain non-fat Greek frozen yogurt using three ingredients!! You read that right THREE ingredients!

  • 32 oz plain Greek yogurt (I used 0%)
  • One pint fat free half and half
  • 1 tbsp vanilla extract
  • 15 drops of Sweetleaf liquid stevia (If you want to sweeten it)

To start, combine Greek yogurt and half and half in a large bowl.

Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

To that whisk in the vanilla extract…

Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

and the Sweetleaf liquid stevia.  As I was using plain Greek yogurt I wanted to bring in a sweetness without changing the flavor of the yogurt or adding in a gazillion calories.

Sweet Leaf Stevia Drops

Lastly I added the yogurt mixture to my ice cream maker and let her rip!  Note that you can still make this without an ice cream maker.  You’ll just want to pour the mixture into shallow containers and freeze until it reaches desired consistency.  I would recommend stirring occasionally.

Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

Now I do recommend watching this ice cream closely.  It’ll turn pretty quickly, after about 15 minutes, so you’ll want to turn off the machine after it reaches your desired consistency.  I churned mine for 20 minutes.

Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

Now what I love about this recipe is that it’s a base recipe and can be used to create a ton of Greek frozen yogurt recipes.  You could swap out the plain Greek yogurt for a flavored one or add in flavored stevia drops as I did.

Sweet Leaf Stevia Drops

Before adding in my flavorings I divided the Greek frozen yogurt into two containers and then flavored each one from there.  To one container I added vanilla creme drops to taste (about 10) and to the other I added hazelnut drops.  They were both so amazingly delicious!

Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

The yogurt freezes hard so you do need to allow to rest before serving it.  I really think this recipe is best to serve right away because I love the soft serve constancy, but it tastes just as great after being frozen.

Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

To the vanilla creme yogurt I added some rainbow sprinkles, adding the perfect touch and sweetness.

Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

I absolutely love this recipe and have a lot of other ideas up my sleeve.

Homemade Greek Frozen Yogurt

I’m thinking mint chocolate chip, orange chocolate chip, cookie dough, and any fruit combo.  The sky is really the limit!

This post is also featured on WIAW.


  1. says

    I’ve never been tempted to get an ice cream maker, until now. This looks delicious! A great way to satisfy a fro-yo craving while being cheaper AND healthier. Can’t wait to see more fro-yo creations :)

  2. says

    That turned out awesome! We have a really really old ice cream maker downstairs. I think if I’m ever tempted to make ice cream though I’ll just buy a new one :) Yours looks a lot less complicated! Lol.

  3. Kim says

    This looks amazing! I’m registering for an ice cream maker (got a loooong way to go lol) but would love to try this without. Any idea about the total calories or calories per serving? ~200? Definitely pinning this one :)

  4. Tara says

    I saw on pinterest you can make your own icecream with ziplock bags. In a small ziplock, add suger, dairy of choice and sweetner.
    close and add that to a larger bag of ice and shake it up for 15 mins. and it will make icecream…….I havent tried it though!

  5. Jennie says

    Oh yummy! Where did you find the Stevia locally? I so want to run to trader joe’s now and make this tonight :)

  6. says

    That looks amazing! I love Greek yogurt, and frozen yogurt… I never thought to try and make one from the other. Thank you for the awesome inspiration :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>